Gaffaweb >
Love & Anger >
1986-02 >
[ Date Index |
Thread Index ]
[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]
From: hsut@ec.purdue.edu (Tsun-Yuk Hsu)
Date: Mon, 17 Feb 86 14:23:27 EST
Subject: A quasi-Greg Earle anti-critic flame :-)
In last week's Village Voice you will find a misinformed and uninformative review of a concert given by everyone's favorite synth- eccentrics, the Residents. Just who is this Mary Passantino who wrote the article??? It's people like her who give critics a bad name :-) :-) (Oops, that should be Rosemary, not Mary. None of us is perfect :-) In her cursory overview of the Residents' work (in that self-righteous all-knowing style typical of many critics, of course), she completely neglects what is generally considered the Residents' technical masterpiece, the concept album ESKIMO. She also mentions in passing the infamous album cover with Dick Clark's head on Hitler's body, and makes the incredible blunder of attributing it to NOT AVAILABLE, when in fact it was on the cover of THIRD REICH AND ROLL. Then Rosemary condemns the Residents' "dinosaur antics" (her exact words) after the COMMERCIAL ALBUM, citing as examples the Mole Trilogy, VILENESS FATS and RESIDUE. Of course self-respecting Residents fan knows that VILENESS FATS contains music from a video the Residents made back in the early '70s, while RESIDUE is a compilation of leftover tracks from many albums, so these two albums are hardly representative of recent trends in the Resident's work. AND of course she neglects to mention the hilarious GEORGE AND JAMES, whose freshness and zaniness would dispell any fears that the Residents are taking themselves too seriously. And I thought misinformation was only a symptom of the sickness of net.music :-) :-) Bill Hsu