Gaffaweb >
Love & Anger >
1991-43 >
[ Date Index |
Thread Index ]
[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]
From: aruss@oucsace.cs.ohiou.edu (Andrew Russ)
Date: Thu, 14 Nov 1991 20:22:47 -0800
Subject: Re: Let me repeat myself..
To: rec-music-gaffa@cis.ohio-state.edu
Newsgroups: rec.music.gaffa
Organization: Ohio University CS Dept., Athens
References: <9111140058.AA07875@garnet.berkeley.edu>
Summary: do record companies have a choice?
If i am a record comapny, doi have the choice of whether or not i label certain albums, the criteria for labelling, the message on the label, the placement and size of the label, etc? That would represent a freedom of choice, would it not? So are the PMRC recommendations a standard that they recommend i use for the benefit of parents. What happens if i don't go along with this "suggestion". Perhaps the PMRC husbands in the Senat will or won't introduce legislation on home taping or digital tape recorders or some other issue of financial importance. At any rate, the No More Censorship Defense Fund (Dead Kennedy's legal project) and Frank Zappa and others have stated that this was the implied carrot and stick behind the major labels. For smaller ones, such as the Alternative Tentacles label that released the Dead Kennedys Frankenchrist album, theycan be sued. The L.A. city attorney admitted in print that their hope in filing the suit regarding the poster in the album (and there was a warning sticker about the poster on the album) was that even if the band, record comapny, and record pressing company (which had nothing to do with the poster) won the suit, that one or more of them would be bankrupted. This was quoted in a newspaper--either in L.A. or San Francisco (included with NMSCDF information package), so here was a local government employee clearly attempting to use intimidation to curtail legal expression. The question is, what would the PMRC do in the case of independent record companies (or majors for that matter) that don't follow their proposal? Some state legislatures have passed or tried to pass (i don't know which or where) laws requiring labels, specifying content and placement and type of records to be stickered; and some (Maryland, i think was one reported in a Rolling Stone about a year ago) also added bans on sales of stickered records to minors. It has been pointed out that the PMRC and related labelling schemes are not aimed at (will not cover) country music or opera. Maybe that's what kids will go for next. andrew